When the Evidence Breaks the Case: Fractography of a Polymer Buckle Failure

A young operator of a small recreational off-highway vehicle was injured when the vehicle struck a hole in a grassy area and tipped onto its side. After the incident, a molded polymer side-release buckle securing the driver-side cab net was found fractured and separated. In the resulting product liability litigation, plaintiffs alleged that the cab net buckle failed during the tip-over, permitting the operator's arm to leave the occupant space and contact the ground. Counsel for the vehicle manufacturer retained ESi to determine the material, the fracture mechanism, and the sequence in which the buckle broke relative to ground contact.

Our Approach

ESi materials consultants inspected the subject vehicle, documenting the construction of the cab net and each of its four attachment points to the vehicle structure. The fractured buckle assembly was recovered with the mating halves still partially engaged, allowing the as-failed geometry and orientation to be reconstructed before any disassembly. 

Macroscopic and microscopic optical examination of both buckle halves established the fracture origins and crack propagation directions. The receptacle half exhibited two deep, closely spaced gouges and localized crushing damage confined to one external face, with no corresponding damage on the opposite face, indicating the assembly had been compressed between a rigid, sharp-edged object and a second, blunt surface. Fracture origins were located on the inner surfaces of the receptacle at the gouge locations, consistent with localized bending that placed those surfaces in tension. One gouge had sheared completely through the wall and fractured a retention prong on the engaged half. Corresponding fractures in the mating half initiated at its rounded corners on the side opposite the external gouging. 

Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy identified the buckle material as polyacetal (POM), a high-strength injection-molding thermoplastic. Fracture surfaces displayed features typical of fast overload separation in POM, with no inclusions, voids, or molding defects present. Published yield strength data for the resin family were used to confirm that the observed permanent deformation required loading well above the material's yield point. 

To test the alleged failure mode, ESi examined an exemplar vehicle and conducted comparative buckle testing. An exemplar buckle assembly was loaded dynamically in tension, replicating an outboard pull on the net from inside the occupant space. The exemplar consistently fractured at a different location and in a different manner than the subject part and matched the fracture locations reported from an independent quasi-static tensile test. The subject buckle showed neither the tensile fracture location nor the tensile fracture morphology.

The Outcome

ESi established that the buckle did not fail in tension and therefore could not have separated from occupant loading during tip over as alleged. The buckle material was free of defects, and the gouging, crushing, and bend-initiated fractures could only have been produced by crushing against a rigid object after the vehicle came to rest on its side. The cab net remained attached throughout the tip-over and separated only at ground impact. The findings gave defense counsel an evidence-based rebuttal to the plaintiffs' failure theory and to opposing expert testing.

Back to Work

Contact ESi and discover how our technical expertise transforms complexity into clarity.